Monday, January 24, 2011

The return of the debtor's prison?

We should absolutely hold fathers responsible for child support and care; however, the application of lengthy prison sentences for people financially unable to provide child support has de facto reincarnated the historic debtor's prison. Prison is not the solution to this issue. In this case, well-placed social disapproval for "dead-beat dads" (hiding assets and concealing income to avoid their financial obligations to their children) has masked fundamental class disparities in enforcement and legal representation between people of means and those living poverty. And, because those living in poverty lack proper legal representation and the available means to readily pay support, in certain cases the application of these laws criminalize poverty itself. In the US, federal debtor's prisons were abolished in 1833 (though it is still legal in six states in a limited capacity). Incarcerating solely for the failure to pay debt remains unconstitional. Furthermore, prison merely contributes to the cycle of poverty rather than providing justice or restitution for those in need of child support.

1 comment:

lin liyi said...

An anti reflective and scratch proof sapphire crystal replica watches sale the dial. Protecting the movement is a caseback engraved with the US hublot replica and with the option of adding a personalized engraving. Will be available with either a black or blue dial and with the option of rado replica uk or a rubber strap with a pin buckle. At the pre order price, this is a lot of replica watches for the money. This is the sort of watch I have to see in real life in order to decide if I like its style or not. Ball has really carved out a pretty unique look for its watches. What replica watches sale me besides the price is that it only a 42mm, not some ridiculous oversized number. So in theory I should like them. But I feel these military seals on the case backs are strictly for poseurs. Shorter versions of the tubes might have been used to make the 12 and 6 numbers. That would be a bit more replica watches sale and balanced looking for the overall aesthetics.