Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Jared Lee Loughner, the Death Penalty, and Us

The Christian Science Monitor today ran an excellent article exploring the possible impacts the Tucson shootings will have on public discourse in the United States. The piece prominently features author David Schmid, whose Natural Born Celebrities: Serial Killers in American Culture is required reading for anyone interested in what our fascination with the macabre says about us.

One of the central questions the article poses is how Loughner's trial will impact public discourse surrounding the death penalty. The past decade has not been kind to capital punishment, as questions of innocence, cost, and deterrence increasingly prompt states to reconsider the sanction's efficacy (my native state, Illinois, is one gubernatorial signature away from outright abolition). Will Loughner, much like Timothy McVeigh, catalyze a renewal of public support for capital punishment (which has been dropping over the years)? Or will Loughner's trial prompt us to see him as "a parable of despair and rootlessness that gnaw at the edges of the American experiment"?

Wherever this discussion goes, it will be a lengthy and painful one. History is littered with instances of sensationalism from media and "tough-on-crime" pandering from politicians, but might there be another way to make sense of Mr. Loughner?

I'm reminded of powerful words from one of my favorite death penalty scholars, Austin Sarat. He writes, "To oppose [capital punishment] is to carry the burden of explaining why the state should not kill people like Timothy McVeigh, of producing a new theory of responsibility and of responsible punishment, and of humanizing inhuman deeds."

In other words, we have our work cut out for us.

1 comment:

lin liyi said...

Many of replica watches had little to do with timekeeping, including altimeters, variometers, telescopes for range finding on artillery, and time fuses for explosives. Depending on the dial color option, each hublot replica will come on either a black, dark blue, or brown leather strap. On their dials, the watches have an outer minute track with the replica watches sale red triangle. All watches are eligible, regardless of the brand, its size, and its country of origin. The company also devoted 25 percent of its advertising to the promotion of war bonds and stamps, a service for which replica watches was awarded a distinguished service certificate. Computron, the angled time display the wearer would rolex replica sale the command button once for the time, and again for the date.